Catwoman

‘Cat lady’ suspected of killing 650 animals
Friday, March 16, 2007
Kevin Mayhood
THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH


Investigators are afraid that a woman who confessed to killing 650 cats and dogs is telling the truth.
Two animal rescuers have told authorities that they gave Maureen McLaughlin about 150 animals during the past five years.
"The numbers no longer sound so ridiculous," said Assistant City Prosecutor Bill Hedrick. "When we searched her apartment, there were almost no vet records and no adoption papers."
And no McLaughlin.
The 56-year-old disappeared before investigators returned to her North Side apartment with a search warrant on Wednesday.
Hedrick described the apartment as "meticulous," with no signs of pets, though neighbors referred to McLaughlin as "the cat lady."
She had called Columbus police over the weekend telling of her crimes.
When investigators from the Franklin County Animal Shelter and Capital Area Humane Society went to McLaughlin’s apartment, she told investigators that she had killed 650 animals and showed them how: She would put an animal in a crate, then drown it in a large trash can filled with water, Hedrick said.
McLaughlin also showed investigators 16 envelopes that had names and descriptions of animals written on them as well as the dates of their deaths, Hedrick said.
The envelopes contained fur or hair.
On Sunday, Cpl. Joe Rock of the Franklin County Department of Animal Care and Control met McLaughlin and videotaped her confessing to killing the animals.
She then led him to the most recent grave, which was in some woods near her home. He said the remains of a shorthaired gray and white cat were inside. McLaughlin was charged with one count of animal cruelty.
Sam Massie, a private security guard and animal rescuer, said he hates to think McLaughlin lied to him all these years.
They met in 2001, and he began bringing dogs and cats to her because she said she was affiliated with an organization that did not euthanize animals, he said.
He estimated he and his wife brought McLaughlin 100 animals.
"It’s heartbreaking," Massie said. "When we heard, it made us sick to our stomachs."
The Humane Society, the County Animal Shelter, the Columbus Dog Connection and the Columbus Cat Welfare Association, where McLaughlin volunteered about a decade ago, said they have not taken in any animals from McLaughlin during the past five years.
Hedrick said that building a case might prove difficult. The statute of limitations prevents his office from prosecuting animal-cruelty cases more than 2 years old.
McLaughlin, who got around by bicycle, told investigators she dropped the bodies in parks and different forested areas around the county.
When investigators returned to her apartment at 4331-B Malin Dr. E. with a search warrant Wednesday, the envelopes, crate and trash can were gone.
McLaughlin had left a note saying what she wanted to be buried with.
A warrant for her arrest was issued wedesday